Smaller specimens of E. nymanniana may appear similar to larger specimens of E. exigua and E. tenella, several specimens may need to be observed for identification. Note that the upper size for E. nymanniana is greater. The dorsal and ventral margins of E. nymanniana are similar in shape and equally spaced. In contrast, the dorsal margin of E. exigua slopes, forming a 'shoulder' toward the apices. Eunotia nymanniana valves are more curved than those of E. tenella and E. neocompacta. Eunotia nymanniana valves are not as strongly arched and the distal raphe end does not curve as far on to the valve face as in E. elegans.