Pinnularia boyeri is larger and has strongly capitate apices.

Pinnularia macilenta has a linear-lanceolate valve outline. The axial area and by the valve apices that are only slightly set-off.

LM scalebar = 10 µm
Length Range
109-158 µm
Width Range
13.9-18.6 µm
Striae in 10 µm
7-9
Pinnularia clericii LM5
Pinnularia clericii LM7
Pinnularia clericii LM1
Pinnularia clericii LM6
Pinnularia clericii LM4
Pinnularia clericii LM3
Pinnularia clericii LM2
Pinnularia clericii LM5 Pinnularia clericii LM7 Pinnularia clericii LM1 Pinnularia clericii LM6 Pinnularia clericii LM4 Pinnularia clericii LM3 Pinnularia clericii LM2

Pinnularia macilenta

(Ehrenb.) Ehrenb. 1843

Length Range
71-124 µm
Width Range
14-16.5 µm
Striae in 10 µm
7-9
Pinnularia macilenta LM6 Pinnularia macilenta LM1 Pinnularia macilenta LM3 Pinnularia macilenta LM4 Pinnularia macilenta LM5 Pinnularia macilenta LM2 Pinnularia macilenta LM7

Also compare to

Pinnularia boyeri

BioData Reference
Patrick and Reimer 1966 Pl 60 Fig 8