Pinnularia borealis is larger, with narrower valve ends and slightly lower stria density.
Pinnularia curticostata is usually a bit more narrow, with a slightly lower stria density.
Pinnularia petersenii has a central fascia.
Pinnularia pseudoparva is very similar, but has subcapitate apices.
BioData Reference
Krammer 2000 Pl 18 Fig 1-4