Pinnularia alabamae is has a similar valve outline, but is much greater in size.

Pinnularia gentilis differs by wider valves, rounded apices, strongly convergent striae at the valve ends, and absence of spines.

LM scalebar = 10 µm
Length Range
135–188 µm
Width Range
18–23 µm
Striae in 10 µm
7-8
Pinnularia rexlowei LM1
Pinnularia rexlowei LM5
Pinnularia rexlowei LM2
Pinnularia rexlowei LM3
Pinnularia rexlowei LM4
Pinnularia rexlowei LM6
Pinnularia rexlowei LM1 Pinnularia rexlowei LM5 Pinnularia rexlowei LM2 Pinnularia rexlowei LM3 Pinnularia rexlowei LM4 Pinnularia rexlowei LM6

Pinnularia alabamae

Krammer 2000

Length Range
180-370 µm
Width Range
32-48 µm
Striae in 10 µm
5-6
Pinnularia alabamae LM5 Pinnularia alabamae LM4 Pinnularia alabamae LM1 Pinnularia alabamae LM7 Pinnularia alabamae LM2 Pinnularia alabamae LM3 Pinnularia alabamae LM6

Also compare to

Pinnularia gentilis

(Donkin) Cleve