Pinnularia neomajor var. frequentis (originally described from New Zealand) is similar in valve outline, but smaller, with valve width 20-22 μm, higher stria density (8–9 in 10 μm), and lacks spines.

Pinnularia gentilis is known from Europe and has wider valves with slightly capitate apices, strongly convergent striae at valve ends, and lacks spines.

LM scalebar = 10 µm
Length Range
130–215 µm
Width Range
20-25 µm
Striae in 10 µm
6-8
Pinnularia spinifera LM5
Pinnularia spinifera LM3
Pinnularia spinifera LM6
Pinnularia spinifera LM1
Pinnularia spinifera LM2
Pinnularia spinifera LM4
Pinnularia spinifera LM7
Pinnularia spinifera LM5 Pinnularia spinifera LM3 Pinnularia spinifera LM6 Pinnularia spinifera LM1 Pinnularia spinifera LM2 Pinnularia spinifera LM4 Pinnularia spinifera LM7

Also compare to

Pinnularia neomajor var. frequentis

Krammer

Pinnularia gentilis

(Donkin) Cleve