Ulnaria ulna differs by wider (6.3-7.7 µm), needle shaped (parallel sides) valves. Ulnaria delicatissima valves have needle shaped valves with short, constricted apices. Fragilaria grunowii has more narrow valves (2-4 µm) and more attenuated, narrow apices. Both Fragilaria crotonensis and Fragilaria tenera are smaller in size. Fragilaria crotonensis often has an inflated central area, has a higher stria density, strongly narrowing apices and forms long, ribbon-like colonies. Fragilaria tenera forms stellate colonies.

LM scalebar = 10 µm
Length Range
61-252 µm
Width Range
4.2-4.9 µm
Striae in 10 µm
11-12
Ulnaria acus LM14
Ulnaria acus LM8
Ulnaria acus LM7
Ulnaria acus LM1
Ulnaria acus LM5
Ulnaria acus LM7
Ulnaria acus LM10
Ulnaria acus LM14 Ulnaria acus LM8 Ulnaria acus LM7 Ulnaria acus LM1 Ulnaria acus LM5 Ulnaria acus LM7 Ulnaria acus LM10

Ulnaria delicatissima

(W.Sm.) Aboal and Silva 2004

Length Range
158.2-262 µm
Width Range
5 µm
Striae in 10 µm
10-11
Ulnaria delicatissima LM15 Ulnaria delicatissima LM16 Ulnaria delicatissima LM18 Ulnaria delicatissima LM19 Ulnaria delicatissima LM20 Ulnaria delicatissima LM21 Ulnaria delicatissima LM22
Length Range
60-72 µm
Width Range
2-3 µm
Striae in 10 µm
17-18
Ansp  Gc112455 5 Ansp  Gc112455 6 Ansp  Gc112455 1 Ansp  Gc112455 11 Ansp  Gc112455 3

Fragilaria tenera

(W.Sm.) Lange-Bert. 1980

Length Range
50-75 µm
Width Range
2.0-2.5 µm
Striae in 10 µm
15-17
F Tenera 114970 3 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 6 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 9 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 5 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 8 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 7 10 Um Bar F Tenera 114970 4 10 Um Bar

Also compare to

Ulnaria ulna

(Nitzsch) Compère

Fragilaria grunowii

Lange-Bert.